Friday, September 7, 2012

Lawyers retained in athlete's '91 death face legal malpractice suit

Jimmy Gates - Clarion Ledger


Almost 21 years ago, Mississippi State University football player Rodney Stowers fractured his right leg in a game in Orlando against the University of Florida.
The talented defensive lineman was carried off the field in a stretcher during the Sept. 28, 1991, game.
No one could have imagined that five days later Stowers, 20, would be dead. He died from an embolism, commonly referred to as a blood clot, resulting from the injury to his leg, according to an autopsy.
Now, two decades later, Stowers' untimely death is the basis for a new lawsuit.
However, the lawsuit in Hinds County Circuit Court isn't a medical malpractice case; it's a legal malpractice case.
The lawsuit is filed against a Jackson attorney for Stowers' mother in her medical malpractice lawsuit filed in 1993 in Lowndes County.
The lawsuit states attorney Robert Germany and his law firm's inaction over an approximately 15-year period on Stowers' mother medical malpractice lawsuit caused it to be dismissed in 2008.
In April, the Mississippi Supreme Court denied a request for the state high court to review the ruling in Lowndes County Circuit Court that dismissed the medical malpractice case.
The new lawsuit, filed on behalf of Stowers' mother, Delie Shepard of Forest, and his daughter, Ashley Stowers of Greenville, states four motions were filed by those sued by the family in the medical malpractice case to have it dismissed because of inaction.
The new lawsuit against Germany and his law firm, Pittman, Germany, Roberts & Welsh, alleges Germany failed to communicate with his clients and lists other alleged breaches and failures of duty to his client.
But Germany, through his attorney, denies the allegations.
"Defendants deny the allegations in the complaint that any duties owed to Ms. Shepard were breached, and defendants will vigorously defend this case," said Joseph Sclafani, an attorney for Germany and his law firm against the legal malpractice lawsuit. "To that end, defendants already have filed a motion to dismiss the case in its entirety."
The Stowers' lawsuit doesn't specify a damage amount sought, but seeks compensatory and punitive damages.
"The responsibility for the dismissal of the litigation in the Circuit Court of Lowndes County ... is directly attributed to the present defendants' dilatory conduct according to the order of the Circuit Court of Lowndes County, Mississippi dated Dec. 19, 2008," the new lawsuit states.
As part of the new lawsuit, the attorney for Stowers' mother and daughter has filed a motion to disqualify Sclafani and other attorneys from the law firm of Brunini, Grower, Grantham & Hewes.
Stowers' family attorney, Michael Crowley of Clinton, says in the motion the firm's attorneys have a conflict of interest. He said in court papers that at least one partner of the firm initially represented Stowers' mother in the medical malpractice lawsuit.
But the Brunini firm said the allegation is unfounded and no member of the firm ever agreed to provide legal services to Shepard.
"No attorney-client relationship has ever existed between the Brunini firm and Ms. Shepard," Sclafani said. "Rather, since the outset of this litigation, the Brunini firm has represented Mr. Germany and his law firm against Ms. Shepard's allegations of professional negligence."